Case Study: A Test of Loyalty and Leadership
You are the Chief Financial Officer of a well-established, medium-to-large family-owned enterprise. The company has grown steadily over the years, largely thanks to a strong sense of loyalty, a flat hierarchy, and a healthy respect for professional autonomy. You have been with the business for over a decade, and in that time, you’ve earned the trust of the family that owns it. You’ve also built a highly capable finance department from the ground up — a team of handpicked professionals who are not only qualified and experienced, but deeply committed to the organisation’s mission and values.
Your role brings you satisfaction, not least because of the freedom you’re afforded to manage your department as you see fit. The owners rarely interfere, and when they do, it’s usually to offer praise or support. It is, by most standards, a dream job — one built on mutual respect and years of loyalty. You usually tend to compromise, but you know it is not an ideal solution.
Then one morning, you receive an unexpected invitation: the company owner would like a private word. When you step into his office, he is all smiles and warmth, but you can tell that something is coming — and it is.
He tells you, with considerable enthusiasm, that his 23-year-old daughter has just completed her degree in business from a local university. He is immensely proud of her and firmly believes she represents the future of the company. In fact, he makes it clear that he hopes she will one day take over the reins.
To help ease her into the business, he asks you to create a role for her within your department — not just any role, but a middle management position where she would report directly to you. He wants her to gain experience under your guidance, and perhaps more importantly, to be seen as a future leader by the rest of the staff.
Herein lies the dilemma.
You know the daughter. You’ve met her several times at company functions and social events. She is charming and personable — but her professional qualifications are questionable at best. Her academic performance was mediocre, and her CV is paper-thin. To your knowledge, she’s never held a full-time job, and her main interests appear to be horses, luxury travel, and spending time with her affluent social circle. She has shown little to no interest in the company’s operations, and even less in the kind of rigorous work your department is known for.
Worse still, your team — the one you’ve spent years building — is composed of high-performing professionals who are likely to bristle at the idea of an inexperienced newcomer leapfrogging into a managerial role. Morale could plummet. You fear that some of your most trusted colleagues might begin looking elsewhere if they perceive that nepotism is starting to override meritocracy.
Now, you are faced with a deeply uncomfortable choice: do you comply with the owner’s request, knowing the potential consequences for team cohesion and performance? Or do you push back — however diplomatically — and risk damaging the close relationship you’ve cultivated with the family, possibly even putting your position in jeopardy?
This isn’t just a question of organisational structure. It’s about loyalty, ethics, leadership, and the delicate balance of power in a family-owned business. How do you honour your commitment to your team without undermining the trust placed in you by the people who ultimately sign your pay cheque?
What do you do?
Let me know if you’d like a version tailored for group discussion or with embedded questions to spark classroom engagement.
Have your say and participate